Dave

owow it's tied

Augie's looks more real Sylar's looks like a video game lol. but i voted for Augie even though Sylar is one of my favorite GFX artists.

First one has a lot of different components, sort of works well. Just the depth is wrong, and there needs to be a better focal + lighting and colour blending too to make it look more realistic.

Second one is clean and simplistic, but needs more... oomfph. It lacks depth, and the text stands out more than the actual render. Needs blending & focal.