Clan Territory Wars - Discussion - Page 12 - Mario Kart Wii - The Biggest Mario Kart Wii Forum
PASSWORD
USERNAME

Clan Territory Wars - Discussion


-


 
Ban TGS entirely 13 44.83%
30 point penalty per match 4 13.79%
Drop all tracks 3 10.34%
Other (please post) 9 31.03%
Voters: 29. You may not vote on this poll

 
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 04:28 AM
  #111 (permalink)  
"
In regards to the WT v cB territory war for DK Summit:


I have included a picture of the final score for the 1st GP. I am also posting the full video and can provide a link when it has uploaded. I don't see any logical reason for making us re do a GP that was completed fairly with proof of the results. And no offense to cB, but it is my belief that they are arguing this position solely because they were losing at the end of the 1st GP.

When WT and ICE had a disputed GP, you decided that we would only redo that single GP. You did not make us restart from the beginning. I believe this is a similar situation.

We have already decided to reschedule the rest of the match, because both sides were having trouble with disconnections this night. I believe it is fair to re do the last 2 GP's completely because we were never able to complete two full races without a disconnection. However, I see no reason why the fully completed 1st GP shouldn't count.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg VID00001 _7__0001.jpg (27.6 KB, 25 views)
 
is idle

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 06:10 AM
  #112 (permalink)  
"
QUOTE:
Originally Posted by JTRamboman View Post
In regards to the WT v cB territory war for DK Summit:


I have included a picture of the final score for the 1st GP. I am also posting the full video and can provide a link when it has uploaded. I don't see any logical reason for making us re do a GP that was completed fairly with proof of the results. And no offense to cB, but it is my belief that they are arguing this position solely because they were losing at the end of the 1st GP.

When WT and ICE had a disputed GP, you decided that we would only redo that single GP. You did not make us restart from the beginning. I believe this is a similar situation.

We have already decided to reschedule the rest of the match, because both sides were having trouble with disconnections this night. I believe it is fair to re do the last 2 GP's completely because we were never able to complete two full races without a disconnection. However, I see no reason why the fully completed 1st GP shouldn't count.
thing is.. if we have to restart a whole GP in a 4v4 if some1 disconnects.. then for me it just makes sense to replay the whole war if we have to reschuelde it to another time
 
Team USA 6-2
Spoiler
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 11:15 AM
  #113 (permalink)  
"
QUOTE:
Originally Posted by JTRamboman View Post
In regards to the WT v cB territory war for DK Summit:


I have included a picture of the final score for the 1st GP. I am also posting the full video and can provide a link when it has uploaded. I don't see any logical reason for making us re do a GP that was completed fairly with proof of the results. And no offense to cB, but it is my belief that they are arguing this position solely because they were losing at the end of the 1st GP.

When WT and ICE had a disputed GP, you decided that we would only redo that single GP. You did not make us restart from the beginning. I believe this is a similar situation.

We have already decided to reschedule the rest of the match, because both sides were having trouble with disconnections this night. I believe it is fair to re do the last 2 GP's completely because we were never able to complete two full races without a disconnection. However, I see no reason why the fully completed 1st GP shouldn't count.
And 5/6 of the disconnects were from you guys... So instead of making you guys grab another sub, we were gonna just redo the whole match...
 
- [Rv]Sphinx -
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 12:34 PM
  #114 (permalink)  
"
QUOTE:
Originally Posted by jkhjunior View Post
thing is.. if we have to restart a whole GP in a 4v4 if some1 disconnects.. then for me it just makes sense to replay the whole war if we have to reschuelde it to another time
I don't see any justification here for redoing a completed GP. You are only saying you "think" we should restart the whole thing, nothing more. In fact, since a 4v4 is more likely to lead to aborted GPs wouldn't it make much more sense to keep the fully completed GP rather than trying to replay it?

QUOTE:
Originally Posted by Sphinx View Post
And 5/6 of the disconnects were from you guys... So instead of making you guys grab another sub, we were gonna just redo the whole match...
Once again, I don't see any true reasoning why the 1st GP should be replayed in this response. You are sort of putting more of the blame for disconnections on our team. Well, in the GP where we actually completed 2 races it was your team that D/C'd. I only see you saying, "we should redo the whole match"...I don't see any actual reason in your response for throwing away the completed GP.
 
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 08:07 PM
  #115 (permalink)  
"
QUOTE:
Originally Posted by JTRamboman View Post
I don't see any justification here for redoing a completed GP. You are only saying you "think" we should restart the whole thing, nothing more. In fact, since a 4v4 is more likely to lead to aborted GPs wouldn't it make much more sense to keep the fully completed GP rather than trying to replay it?



Once again, I don't see any true reasoning why the 1st GP should be replayed in this response. You are sort of putting more of the blame for disconnections on our team. Well, in the GP where we actually completed 2 races it was your team that D/C'd. I only see you saying, "we should redo the whole match"...I don't see any actual reason in your response for throwing away the completed GP.
um... we d/c once... u guys disconnected 5 times which put a total of 5-6 races...
I don't know why you are posting... I asked Q the question, no need for your post.
Last edited by Sphinx; 09-19-2008 at 08:13 PM.
 
- [Rv]Sphinx -
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 09:44 PM
  #116 (permalink)  
"
Lol, I posted because this is a discussion thread. Three different members from your clan have posted their opinions on the matter, presenting their view on why this issue should be resolved in your favor. I'm not supposed to respond to that? Give me a break. Of course you think there is no need for me to post. But I see no problem with a civil discussion on the matter. Feel free to either stop responding, or present a counter-argument, but don't tell me I shouldn't be posting.
 
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 10:50 PM
  #117 (permalink)  
"
QUOTE:
Originally Posted by JTRamboman View Post
Lol, I posted because this is a discussion thread. Three different members from your clan have posted their opinions on the matter, presenting their view on why this issue should be resolved in your favor. I'm not supposed to respond to that? Give me a break. Of course you think there is no need for me to post. But I see no problem with a civil discussion on the matter. Feel free to either stop responding, or present a counter-argument, but don't tell me I shouldn't be posting.
A few of your members read my post and said they respected it... I don't get what your point is. I just want to stop arguing and let Q decide.
 
- [Rv]Sphinx -
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 11:02 PM
  #118 (permalink)  
"
Reschedule for the last 2 GPs. If you have a result for the 1st one, then you do not need to do it again.
 
Perhaps a gift if you join?
XBL Gamertag: BiteyQ
Currently Playing: Left 4 Dead, Halo Wars Demo
Aiming for the Top


Mario Kart Wii - The largest concentration of lucky noobs who think they have skill in any video game outside of Mario Party.
has no status.

Old
 
 
09-19-2008, 11:36 PM
  #119 (permalink)  
"
QUOTE:
Originally Posted by Sphinx View Post
A few of your members read my post and said they respected it... I don't get what your point is. I just want to stop arguing and let Q decide.
I have no problem with any of your posts. I thought we were having a discussion about the issue. And then you told me I shouldn't be posting. So I responded again. That is where I am coming from. I have nothing else to say, unless you feel like continuing the discussion.
 
[FV]CRizzo

Old
 
 
09-22-2008, 03:49 AM
  #120 (permalink)  
"
To The Clan Territory War Staff, Q:

I'm here on behalf of the clan "Chaos Breed" to inform you that our territory war with Team Blaze has still not happen. I personally have been stopping by their thread and sent PMs to their leaders and they haven't replied. I don't know if we have to wait certain amount of time...But it's been long enough.
I really didn't want to do this but I've spent a week coming over to their thead and 6 days since I've sent the PMs to the leaders. I can't make it to their chat because my system doesn't support it, and every time I stopped by I left them the link to our chat.

They told me they're to busy with school...But my clan won't take that excuse, because we too have attend school and have been able to make all our schedule matches and commitents during weekends and some late wars during weekdays.

I suggest something must be done.

Thanks you.
 
 


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
 
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump