Melee's last tier list was in 2006.

So you learn the controls and now you're pro? I doubt it.

Lol, you kinda did call yourself a pro. Sure, we can play sometime. But not if you're gonna pick Meta-Knight, sorry. Capt. Falcon vs. Meta-Knight is just one-sided and really not fun. >_<

Well, they 'were' released on a yearly basis. There are still Melee players around, so a new one will be released some time later, unless if they hit the mark this time with the tier list.

No, he said that he's considered by some people (don't ask who) a pro, he didn't said that he consider himself as a pro. See the difference? =P

I still play Melee (way more than Brawl), but I haven't been on Smashboards in some time now mainly because of all the new Brawl people. If a new list is going to be made then Marth is definitely moving up. I'm not too sure another one is going to be made for Melee, I'm pretty sure the SBR are more focused on developing the Brawl metagame

Btw I checked Smashboards just now and I don't think this list is official.
First thing I noticed is that it's in the North Atlantic sub-forums (some place to put an official tier list)
Second it seems that not much effort was put into the bottom half as obviously stated in the OP.
Finally, just because it's posted from a well known pro smasher doesn't really make it official, even though it's pretty easy to agree with this list.

Just wait for the Smash Back Room to announce the list, usually a mod does this.

Excuse my reeding powahz.

Ya, like I said, another Melee tier list won't be out for some time. =p

As said millions of times XD, I didn't say it was the OFFICIAL tier list. But by official, I mean that it's from the pros, like Chillin and M2K. I think it's too early for the OFFICIAL tier list. But I'm pretty sure you can agree that the tier list is somewhat accurate here. Sorry if I misled you with 'official'. =s

At first I thought they finally made a Brawl tier list lol. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

Also here's a fun fact: M2K actually disagrees with a majority of this list. I read his complaints in the thread, I think it's on page 6 or 7.

Nah, there are tons of dummy Brawl tier lists. But this one seems the most accurate (even though it's not completely accurate itself).

Lol, anything with M2K is very misleading. If M2K says so-and-so is better than so-and-so, then it must be true. Soon enough, Chuck Norris jokes will start after him.

I dont bring out My Meta unless.. You spam, your a MK mainer yourself (I <3 MK DITTOZ), Its an important match, or if im trying to find combos for him. Or if you bring out snake. I hate fighting snake with MK but he is MK's biggest counter. So ill only bring him out under those circumstances. Other than that. ill use other characters. And now that i look at what i said. I did call myself a pro lolz. But anyway. Wanna brawl?

Back on subject
I just think MK shouldnt be alone at god tier. Snake and Marth should be up there too. Or at least GaW.